GD TopicsBest GD TopicsCurrent Gd topics list

India should be reorganized into smaller states.

Favor

  • By dividing India in small parts and concentrating on problems region vise; there are more chances of better growth.
  • We need governance at small level so that we can manage and regulate life more appropriately

Against

  • Dividing India is not solution of problem. Because it would create hatred and divergence between people of 2 states.
  • More over dividing on basis of caste and religion is creating more issues like minor ,major population with in newly created state
  • The resources of the India become property of that state so other states become insecure and only people of a particular reason become richer.

Conclusion

  • Recognizing India into smaller states is not a good idea
  • Dividing India into smaller states on basis of castes and religions is not a good idea.

GD Topics


Points added by members


Added by: Divya kvs



Point: the development of the new state takes much time, mean while it looses all the benifits which the former state gets..therefore states should not be divided



Date: 2014-09-10 21:35:53

Added by: emran



Point: dividing India is not the great idea.because we have already seen that division of states not became fruitful in the development process.if we divide India caste



Date: 2014-07-19 01:51:36

Added by: sid



Point: India is known in the entire world for its unity in diversity. But if we reorganise the nation into further smaller states on the basis of religion, caste, language, majorities etc we will make a nest for, communal riots and clashes, to hatch in. This will also led to hatred among the people of different states, causing our people to drift apart.



Date: 2014-06-21 16:07:18

Added by: amala



Point: In my opinion,dividing india is not a good idea.because britishers tried to divide our country but we fought with them and finally we have our india in our hand,now politicians are look like britishers,they are trying to divide our country for their power only not for the people sake.dividing india may cause many riots between indians based in the religion,culture etcits not a good sign to our country growth



Date: 2014-05-19 06:45:32

Added by: Rishiraj



Point: It may result into riots.Dividing is not solution,Indian people lack in unity as compared to other country.Every politician or people work with unity and pure heart they can build powerful country.



Date: 2014-03-26 13:21:14

Added by:



Point: should the states be made smaller



Date: 2014-03-19 07:21:00

Added by: Unnikrishnan S P



Point: Hai friends its unni here... i would like throw some light over the topic. India was one of the richest country when British came here. They saw the possibilty of dividing us so that we would weak which they did and continued till 14august 1947. After the British it is now the chance of the politians do, which we should not support. dividing us futher into smaller states can make make as weak and we may move back to old days, being another colony to some powerful nation. Friends we are the 7th largest nation in the world lets remain the same.



Date: 2014-03-16 10:49:15

Added by: Unnikrishnan S P



Point: you can also mention divide and rule policy which was taken while the ritish was here



Date: 2014-03-16 10:34:46

Added by: sailatha mareddy



Point: im supposed to dividing india .. bcoz the allocation of funds by the central can never be evenly distributed so some parts of people stand to lose nd remain backward nd the people in smaller states have better living standards nd the more effiecency in the adminstaration nd less pressure in the perfomance of government



Date: 2014-02-20 12:35:04

Added by: archana chapariya



Point: friends it is wrong to divide telangna becoz in future other state will alsopropose to divide them and on day india nation become many country not state so, its just the making india weak and allow to indians to break their unity. Its the game of politics becoz telangna has the 17 seats and now congress are supporting telangna



Date: 2014-02-20 00:44:02

Added by: pragati



Point: we should be together as citizenes of nation so no one will try to dominate us



Date: 2014-02-06 11:23:54

Added by: Krishna Kumar Bhaarateey



Point: Do wee need so many Politicians ? One Good MP from Each District is enough. No States Assemblies; no CMs, No MLAs



Date: 2014-01-31 11:49:59

Added by: sathish sharma [tirunelveli] student



Point: hai! to everybody, i want to share my thougts about this to you,in my point of view dividing the india by means of land is good or not. you will get it from my below answer,,okay.first of all i want to share this to you that in 1950 in the south india named MADRAS PRESIDENCY exists over it includes some parts of karnataka,kerala,andhra,orissa



Date: 2014-01-13 01:45:00

Added by: Shivam



Point: India is country , is known by its unity , it should nt be divided bt we make our rules n regulation more better, divide smthng is nt d solution,bt if we r talking abt the other hand , by dividng india , we use d natural resources very wel, we have a better adminstartion ,to reduce unemployment.Bt one of d states becom more rich , n other 1 becm poor.So at last i would sugest , it should be divided.



Date: 2013-10-18 21:07:23

Added by: Neha Rajput



Point: In my opinion, India is a country with diverse cultures , languages, religions, castes. If we go on dividing nation inro fragments on these pity issues, then it will land up in multiple states, things will become complex and unmanagebale.Other countries will be laughing at us which already wants to divide and weaken India.



Date: 2013-09-11 21:34:25

Added by: K.S.Lakshmi Narasimhan



Point: formation of states basing merely on the language of an area is not a wise decision, instead it should be based on regional compactness apart langauage



Date: 2013-08-25 00:34:21

Added by: K.S.Lakshmi Narasimhan



Point: formation of states basing merely on the language of an area is not a wise decision, instead it should be based regional compactness apart langauage



Date: 2013-08-25 00:30:38

Added by: sam



Point: According to me india being a small country as lots of problems.So it has to be divided into smaller parts and problems should be solved and equally developed so the the growth of the country will be good....



Date: 2013-08-23 02:57:33

Added by: raghu



Point: In the vast world, India is a smaller and one of the smallest country, being a part of the Asian Continent. As already its area is not so bigger, it should be kept as United. If it is bifurcated, many problems may arise between the people in the fields of water, gdp, production and so on.



Date: 2013-08-21 20:15:31

Added by: praveen banachod



Point: i think india should not be revognige into smaller states becouse making smaller states is the game plan of polititions after making new states they will have lot of apportunities and normaly comn man does not like this and at the same time it is against the deveolopment



Date: 2013-08-16 11:58:11

Added by: Harsh



Point: I think that India should not be divided into several states because the unity of the state will be break down.I think that states are not break down into many parts.



Date: 2013-08-12 11:30:08

Added by: mc135844



Point: the dividing of a state in smaller parts is the way to differenciate between the people of a country and it will also dividing the sources of states. In india there are many groups demanding the division of state. hence on my point of view state should not divide in more smaller parts



Date: 2013-02-19 12:10:34

Added by: ajay choudhary



Point: according to my opinine we should n't india in to smaller states because smaler states makes india greater.with division according religion or caste we can't developed india.



Date: 2013-02-19 02:55:10

Added by: Bhanu prakash.



Point: some people argue that dividing India will lead to better governance but what happened with jharkhand is all known to us. So dividing India is no more the solution of the problem unless our leaders are going to take it seriously.I think that instead of dividing India we should focus on how to make our law and regulation more better .



Date: 2013-02-08 08:25:16

Added by: Rohith Varma



Point: My Opinion is that,if v divide any particular state into smaller then the reputation,name,fame for the state which was there when thy r combined will be lost due to lot many issues...The aggegate area of the state will be lost///////////best example..if Uttar pradesh is divide into smaller then the name at present as bigger state will b gone easily......Apart from this it is good to divide states in case of Telangana from Andhra pradesh so as to fullfill employment probes



Date: 2013-01-17 03:19:17

Added by: dia



Point: according to me.. divu=ision can never be the key to success and from past we got a very good example and sabak. india and pakistan are still fighting.. so more smaller states divided at any pretext does no good..divide and rule never works..



Date: 2012-09-03 14:03:55

Added by: shabana



Point: I believe dividing india is the one of the solution for the problems that we are facing today.for development,education,etc.,even government has an ability to concentrate on crisis.



Date: 2012-08-28 10:45:00

Added by: shazia maqsood



Point: no it is not the best option to divide india into smaller parts,think if india n pakistan are together than we are the most powerful country of the world.the best power to defeat the enemy is the unity.if india divide in to smaller part than our power Will b decrease.



Date: 2012-04-16 03:44:12

Added by: hbk



Point: superficially it seems that dividing india is the good idea because then we will have smaller chunks to deal with but it is not favorable in terms of india's unity,dividing in terms of any criterion will have detrimental effect in the serenity of india.chasm of caste and religion has been their from a long and is has been narrowed by severe efforts,but if we divide the india then we would be deepning that chasm and that is not appreciable.



Date: 2012-02-22 02:08:46

Added by: Ashwini



Point: if u think that if we divide india in to smaller state and we should on the path of dveloped it is not possible,until if we r not change.....



Date: 2011-11-27 16:13:19

Added by: RANJEET KUMAR



Point: We are not dividing our India .Its a incredible,vast and emotional India.we are just taking the total control of our India just like management,to know the problem of every part of our country and solve all those problems then our country will healthy country.So we have not to concentrate on all those rummer and make it proud and also make to proud to be feel an Indian.



Date: 2011-11-11 09:45:01

Added by: NIKITA



Point: india should be divided into smaller states not on the basis of linguistic or culture or religion but on the basis of the defined limited population. there would be better use of resources, state facilities,employment opportunities and many more. better control/administration will be witnessed.control on smaller state is any day better than controlling larger states keeping in mind the strict rules to be implemented and new methodologies to be adopted.



Date: 2011-10-21 00:28:32

Added by: Parul



Point: dividing the problem into smaller parts would need more concentration into each, which in my view is difficult task to perform.



Date: 2011-10-15 20:18:43

Added by: vijaya lakshmi



Point: India should not be divided into smaller states becoz mainly it will make sure for the financial loss to government



Date: 2011-09-18 23:15:30

Added by: ajay



Point: dividation of any country in states is good for managing the problems, but india is already divided in 27 states ,it already creates a no of issues like north south , marathi , further division of indua will cause more complexicity and issues.so reorganised india in smaller states will decrease the growth rate of county



Date: 2011-08-08 03:31:35

Added by: DJ



Point: For people of this nation to truly live in prosperity and peace, India should break up into several smaller states.The best thing that happened to the Indian sub-continent is Partition. Just imagine if Pakistan and Bangladesh were still a part of India. We would all be living in misery. Partition is the only reason why Indians are in a better position than the Pakis or Banglas.



Date: 2011-08-05 00:42:39

Added by: rajesh



Point: dividing into severals parts leads to more politicians, if politicians are more then more will be corruption



Date: 2011-07-16 15:12:16

Added by: vivek srivastava



Point: small states can be governed easily because of its limited ....areapopulationrescourcesand this accurate data can also be easily maintained at the central levelif the rescouces are used by limited number of people ..... it can be used more effectively



Date: 2011-05-15 12:55:31

Added by: Gouri



Point: "india should be reorganised into smaller states".What is your opinion on this subject?Give reasons in support of your opinion.



Date: 2011-01-05 00:09:51

Added by: chandu



Point: India should not be divided in smaller states,because small state means better for administration and progress of the state but the story is quite different in our country smaller state means more post for politicians and more corruption and less development.



Date: 2010-08-12 19:01:40

Added by: Chinmay



Point: Against:
India should not be divided in smaller states ;and the governing system and the judicial architecture should be made more better and wiser that it could resolve the issues on their respective levels.



Date: 2010-07-13 12:13:31