Managerial skills learnt from classroom can never match those learnt from experience.
Favour
- In class rooms a student can only read books and read case studies which are not the experience of him so it not imprints in his mind and lost soon.
- It is a fact that text books can cover only few situations where as real life is combination of many other complex situations
- Reading just gives students glimpse how they should react in a particular situation but when that particular situation comes in real life it depends on his personality that how he reacts.
- In real life a situation and its memory is combination of reaction, result and feelings like sadness, happiness ,winning, loss which becomes part of human mind forever which not happens in classroom
Against
- Books cover all basic situation to describe all complex situations so basically a manager face one of the situation almost all time
- Institutes are providing experience to students by using techniques of drama and role play in classroom which is a great way of learning real life problems in real time scenarios
Conclusion
- Real time experience is always more important than the classroom studies.
- In classroom studies one can learn more using modern techniques of learning.
Add your point
Points added by members
Added by: Sarbashis Ghosh
Point: The difference basically lies between theory and practical.in classroom people learn things theoritically,whereas experience comes out of practical things.so,if you come across something in your real life you will be able to react into situations in future better than somebody who has learnt things theoritically.but theoritical experience can be better if some real life experiences are put in the form of role play,drama,etc.this will make people proactive and not reactive.
Date: 2013-03-10 09:12:17
Point: The difference basically lies between theory and practical.in classroom people learn things theoritically,whereas experience comes out of practical things.so,if you come across something in your real life you will be able to react into situations in future better than somebody who has learnt things theoritically.but theoritical experience can be better if some real life experiences are put in the form of role play,drama,etc.this will make people proactive and not reactive.
Date: 2013-03-10 09:12:17
Added by: priyanka shrivastava
Point: experiences are of great reality......... so reading and experience something is totally different.
Date: 2012-08-17 04:20:56
Point: experiences are of great reality......... so reading and experience something is totally different.
Date: 2012-08-17 04:20:56
Added by: vishal
Point: i dont think that there is any good teacher than real life experiences,, in schools we omly learn the basics,, and the fundamental of one's field,, but after we come to the real world,, all seems to be out of course,, after that its just you,, who need to lean from our mistakes,, being in differnt situation
Date: 2012-08-05 01:31:30
Point: i dont think that there is any good teacher than real life experiences,, in schools we omly learn the basics,, and the fundamental of one's field,, but after we come to the real world,, all seems to be out of course,, after that its just you,, who need to lean from our mistakes,, being in differnt situation
Date: 2012-08-05 01:31:30
Added by: Suraj Sharma ICFAI university Nagaland
Point: In my point of view: I think that to get the experience, first we have to learn from book after that we are going to feel in our real life with our theories which lies in our book which help us to face the real situation because first learn from book after that get the experience which are going to come in our real life.
Date: 2012-02-20 09:20:36
Point: In my point of view: I think that to get the experience, first we have to learn from book after that we are going to feel in our real life with our theories which lies in our book which help us to face the real situation because first learn from book after that get the experience which are going to come in our real life.
Date: 2012-02-20 09:20:36
Added by: venkat
Point: the students are solving issue by many techniques in classroom and sometimes that helps in solving the problem in real life situation.
Date: 2012-01-21 03:07:11
Point: the students are solving issue by many techniques in classroom and sometimes that helps in solving the problem in real life situation.
Date: 2012-01-21 03:07:11
Added by: mukesh kumar saxena iibs indore
Point: i think managerial skills are more needy rather than class room study.the point is that which one is more helpful ur career so my suggestion is that practical knowledge is very needy to seeing current situation because today whether u having more degree but if u dont have experience in particular field than u can not do anything like for example- engineering,piolot and etc
Date: 2011-11-10 22:41:36
Point: i think managerial skills are more needy rather than class room study.the point is that which one is more helpful ur career so my suggestion is that practical knowledge is very needy to seeing current situation because today whether u having more degree but if u dont have experience in particular field than u can not do anything like for example- engineering,piolot and etc
Date: 2011-11-10 22:41:36
Added by: shajahan pathan
Point: of course managerial skills in personnel experience doesnt match with those skills which are thought in class room..but class room skills are very helpful to tackle the real time experience very easily
Date: 2011-10-16 22:09:30
Point: of course managerial skills in personnel experience doesnt match with those skills which are thought in class room..but class room skills are very helpful to tackle the real time experience very easily
Date: 2011-10-16 22:09:30
Added by: Raghuraman.S
Point: There is a famous quote which japan follows:"I Hear : I Forget I Saw : I Remember I Do : I Understand"
Date: 2011-08-24 15:37:22
Point: There is a famous quote which japan follows:"I Hear : I Forget I Saw : I Remember I Do : I Understand"
Date: 2011-08-24 15:37:22
Added by: shrinath
Point: books can cover only a few situations but when it comes to real time situations its all about that instant..one can learn these skills with experience..but experience without classroom skills can't help though..because classroom skills help's one to think in that particular direction.
Date: 2011-07-22 21:34:24
Point: books can cover only a few situations but when it comes to real time situations its all about that instant..one can learn these skills with experience..but experience without classroom skills can't help though..because classroom skills help's one to think in that particular direction.
Date: 2011-07-22 21:34:24
Added by: mufaddal johar selanawala.
Point: managerial skills are gained from the elders as well as by bookish knowledge because are elders have already gone through that phase.
Date: 2011-07-18 18:37:08
Point: managerial skills are gained from the elders as well as by bookish knowledge because are elders have already gone through that phase.
Date: 2011-07-18 18:37:08
Added by: ashutosh jaiswal
Point: theories and princiies are mere ideality that we learn and often we come across some of the exampies already faced practically but in real time experience we have to face problems that are distraction from those idealities so after classroom,real time experience is necessary.
Date: 2011-07-10 09:18:34
Point: theories and princiies are mere ideality that we learn and often we come across some of the exampies already faced practically but in real time experience we have to face problems that are distraction from those idealities so after classroom,real time experience is necessary.
Date: 2011-07-10 09:18:34
Added by: archana pal
Point: Managerial skills which we learn from the classroom always not helping in our practical life. Practically sometimes we have to take some important decision which affects our organisation so on that time our practical thinking is more important than our bookish knowledge. In professionalism we have to be prepare for the any type of situation
Date: 2011-07-08 15:40:06
Point: Managerial skills which we learn from the classroom always not helping in our practical life. Practically sometimes we have to take some important decision which affects our organisation so on that time our practical thinking is more important than our bookish knowledge. In professionalism we have to be prepare for the any type of situation
Date: 2011-07-08 15:40:06
Added by: Jogamaya Panda
Point: One gets only a basic idea from books in classroom but in a particular situation one learns from enviornment what to do.
Date: 2011-05-30 12:30:36
Point: One gets only a basic idea from books in classroom but in a particular situation one learns from enviornment what to do.
Date: 2011-05-30 12:30:36
Added by: Jogamaya Panda
Point: One gets only a basic idea from books in classroom but in a particular situation one learns from enviornment what to do.
Date: 2011-05-30 12:22:06
Point: One gets only a basic idea from books in classroom but in a particular situation one learns from enviornment what to do.
Date: 2011-05-30 12:22:06
Added by: Sudhansu Bhusan Panda
Point: in my point of view the management skill learnt from the experience is more helpful,u already got some idea on that field but theory necessary bcoz if he don't have theoritical knowledge experienced knowledges are not going to helpful to him.
Date: 2011-01-08 12:01:20
Point: in my point of view the management skill learnt from the experience is more helpful,u already got some idea on that field but theory necessary bcoz if he don't have theoritical knowledge experienced knowledges are not going to helpful to him.
Date: 2011-01-08 12:01:20
Added by: pavani chowdary
Point: both the experience and classroom teaching are equally important but only experience can show you the real world experience to gain knowledge
Date: 2011-01-03 12:01:23
Point: both the experience and classroom teaching are equally important but only experience can show you the real world experience to gain knowledge
Date: 2011-01-03 12:01:23
Added by: satya
Point: its cool and intresting to go through of htis topic.i really feel soo inspired.
Date: 2010-12-27 11:35:29
Point: its cool and intresting to go through of htis topic.i really feel soo inspired.
Date: 2010-12-27 11:35:29
Added by: Faisal shaik
Point: book theories you keep in mind always you have to perform any where but real time you face one problem alternatively you know that how solve the problem, the situation creating at the spot in real time if you had the guts to solve you will be in your life
Date: 2010-08-10 15:42:35
Point: book theories you keep in mind always you have to perform any where but real time you face one problem alternatively you know that how solve the problem, the situation creating at the spot in real time if you had the guts to solve you will be in your life
Date: 2010-08-10 15:42:35
Added by: Chaitanya Velamuri
Point: Although i can't use extreme phrase that it never matches but yes for sure the real experience are quite varied from those that are printed around in books. as mentioned in several comments, many books give upon certain stone turning case studies which almost are standard in many books and in some other there are certain other cases quoted which the author might himself have experienced it or has seen that happen. so each one's story differs but each one is that factual enough. one can argue that books cover lot many aspects,no doubt in that but when situation actually approaches you no one encroaches to think what was the solution mentioned in the book and how to tackle it--the behavior of ours at that moment is instant. and if we take a wrong step,it is automatically registered in our mind and when second time we go through such phases we think of other alternatives.
Date: 2010-05-30 07:29:13
Point: Although i can't use extreme phrase that it never matches but yes for sure the real experience are quite varied from those that are printed around in books. as mentioned in several comments, many books give upon certain stone turning case studies which almost are standard in many books and in some other there are certain other cases quoted which the author might himself have experienced it or has seen that happen. so each one's story differs but each one is that factual enough. one can argue that books cover lot many aspects,no doubt in that but when situation actually approaches you no one encroaches to think what was the solution mentioned in the book and how to tackle it--the behavior of ours at that moment is instant. and if we take a wrong step,it is automatically registered in our mind and when second time we go through such phases we think of other alternatives.
Date: 2010-05-30 07:29:13
Added by: Saud
Point: Its not about how to gain a skill, its about matching the real time with theories.
Class room provides you the platform but in the actual scenario you learn more being a part of industry where so many dependents follow your decisions. Wrong decision are never forgotten,giving you a chance to improve and good ones no doubt builds confidence.
Date: 2010-05-26 18:01:09
Point: Its not about how to gain a skill, its about matching the real time with theories.
Class room provides you the platform but in the actual scenario you learn more being a part of industry where so many dependents follow your decisions. Wrong decision are never forgotten,giving you a chance to improve and good ones no doubt builds confidence.
Date: 2010-05-26 18:01:09
Added by: Vijay
Point: If experience is taken, without having the skills in classroom will not have a better result. so, management skills taken in classroom helps the person to think in that direction.
Date: 2010-05-16 11:17:37
Point: If experience is taken, without having the skills in classroom will not have a better result. so, management skills taken in classroom helps the person to think in that direction.
Date: 2010-05-16 11:17:37
Added by: Suresh Wadhwani
Point: Management is the mixture of science and art. So one should be equipped with theories and principles first then he/she can implement it in real which is art.
Date: 2010-02-13 01:18:09
Point: Management is the mixture of science and art. So one should be equipped with theories and principles first then he/she can implement it in real which is art.
Date: 2010-02-13 01:18:09