GD TopicsBest GD TopicsCurrent Gd topics list

Foreign direct investment (FDI) in retail sector.

Background

The recent cabinet decision on FDI in retail has triggered protests by opposition and key allies of the ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA), who are demanding a roll back of the policy. The hour-long meeting held in Parliament House failed to resolve the logjam in the two Houses as opposition parties, led by BJP and the Left, stuck to their stand and demanded rollback of the Cabinet decision to allow 51 per cent FDI in multi-brand retail. Though at present only 53 cities with population not less than 10 lakh in the country have been identified for FDI As the fourth-largest economy in the world in PPP terms, India is a preferred destination for FDI. During 2000-10, the country attracted $178 billion as FDI.

Favor

  • This will bring modern technology to the country.
  • Improve rural infrastructure. It would help build infrastructure and create a competitive market.
  • Reduce wastage of agricultural produce.
  • Enable our farmers to get better prices for their crops.
  • Consumers will get commodities of daily use at reduced prices.
  • Biggest beneficiary of this would be small farmers, who would be able to improve productivity and realize higher remuneration by selling directly to large organized players and shorten the chain from farm to consumers.
  • Government too stands to gain by this move through more transparent and accountable monitoring of goods and supply chain management systems. It can expect to receive an additional US$ 25-30 billion by way of taxes
  • Opening of retail can be seen as a solution for food inflation, which has been confounding policy-makers. FDI in retail would help in building much needed back end infrastructure. Additionally, he said, investments in cold storage chain infrastructure would reduce loss of agricultural produce and provide more options to farmers.

Against

  • Our interest rates today are as high as 14 per cent to 16 per cent how do we compete with the economies which have a 4 per cent interest rate. Our infrastructure our trade facilitations our labor laws, all these factors collectively don't make India low cost. So do you want India to become a center where we allow foreign companies to come in and set up these large chains which eventually instead of selling domestic products out sourcing internationally the cheapest sources and selling those products. Please remember domestic retail normally sources domestically, international retail sources internationally because they source from the cheapest sources.
  • Even if big retail companies help the farmers in resurrecting their economy, what plan does the government has for millions of middlemen who are part of the business process chain that ensures manufactured products reach end users.
  • We engage millions of uneducated and semi-educated people at various stages of retail business spread across towns and cities but we are afraid that Tesco and Wal-Mart will only engage smart and educated workforce in small strength, comparatively. Conclusion
  • Government is taking this decision in good faith. Few persons and lobbies controlling the rates of food commodities in India. And bringing more competition in market will bring better prices for buyers as well as sellers of commodities. Parties protesting against FDIs in retail have choice to not allow FDIs in the states they are ruling. Government should make a regulatory body for the commodity trade as we have for cellular services.
Add your point
Write to us about your view on this topic...

Write in the box:


Email address: (Will not be shared.)




Name: (max 100 character)






Points added by members


Added by: Narendra Kumar Sharma



Point: supoose in any town there are 100 shops and in these shops on an average four person from the family of owner of shop is directly or indirectly employed through that shop.so total become 400 employed people without requiring any specific skill.on other hand on wallmart in town will employ maximum 40 person and only qualified persons.so you can see employment status.and at starting they might give lucrative rate to farmers but later on will they compromise with quality?.no, and every farmer will be forced to sell to retailers at a price fixed by retailers acvording to quality. only top quality will be supported and other will suffer very badly.



Date: 2014-08-23 02:37:12

Added by: ANKIT LOHANI



Point: with the coming of the FDI there is a lot of opportunity for the consumer there is a lots of variety of product at cheaper rates with the coming of FDI in INDIA lots and lots of employment is generated with it help the youth and the nation second reason is thatgovernment will get a tax of 25 billion third reason is that it provide a platform for the farmer where they get affordable price of their products and minimize the role of middle man who use to take undue advantage fourth reason it allow the foreign currency to come to india



Date: 2014-08-16 20:41:06

Added by: laxmi



Point:
In my point of view , fdi is good for our country in many ways. There are many companies in india by which we are gettin a lots of profit.every company products their goods. As we can see that honda , dominor pizza,many types of chinese mobiles, duke and extra extra.... Which are very important for us .



Date: 2014-08-02 10:40:20

Added by: siddharth mehta



Point: I think that FDI is mandatory in retail sector as it will help build foreign currency and it will enhance our economic growth of our country and better infrastructure will come to our country... it will bolster our GDP and also remains a agriculture driven economy it will help farmers who will directly sell their produce and thus eradicate the middlemen which are responsible for corruption modern technology will come and most skilled employees....last but not the least as India has less resources and more population so effective utilization is required which gives max output at min cost....so according to my perception FDI is must.....



Date: 2014-06-01 09:32:43

Added by: PARVEJ ALAM KHAN



Point: i think FDI in retail sector will give enhancement in econmic growth as well as it creats more job opportunities.it has more positives aspect and only few negatves aspects



Date: 2014-04-29 02:15:45

Added by: VINEET THAKUR



Point: I m in the favour of fDI as we know india suffering from unemployment. ..this is the only way to solve this..and it will increase economy of india....



Date: 2014-03-27 10:31:22

Added by: Ranjeet_Great



Point: I need some answer..Profit gained by those foreign companies will go to their nation or that will be in india..?What types of jobs they will provide us.Sales man or sales girls...?What is the plan for middle class people who have their shops..?They could go in loss..I think their must be some rules like as..1.employments for indians in their companies.2.limited years of bonds be sign.3.Except India no other countries can take any type of decisions regarding those malls..4.some products must be from indian companies.



Date: 2014-03-18 04:41:50

Added by: P C Saboo



Point: Yes we should accept FDI. It will also improve the tax revenue of GOI. Only thing GOI should regulate it properly so that these entity may not behave like East India Company.



Date: 2014-03-12 01:47:57

Added by: siddhant gupta



Point: i think FDI is benefial for indian economy, because it create employment in the country, it will improve our economic condition, it will provide commodities at cheaper rates, and most important it will bring new technology. From my point of view FDI is beneficial deal for indian economy.



Date: 2014-02-13 01:39:15

Added by: Ashu Khajuria



Point: I think althouh there are some limitations of FDI but its benefits are large for any UDC contary like india.Inaia is a large populated county,most of the peoples are unemployed so FDI generates more employment opportunities and solve that problem and also solve the problem of poverty to some extent. The other important benefit of FDI is that it use the unutilized resource.



Date: 2014-02-02 05:35:51

Added by: Keshab Kumar Nayak



Point: (1) Growth in Economy (2) Job Opportunities(3) Benefits to Farmers(4) Benefits to consumers (5) Lack of Infrastructure(6) Cheaper Production facilities (7) Availability of new technology (8) Long term cash liquidity (9) Conducive for the countryís economic growth (10) FDI opens up a new avenue for Franchising



Date: 2014-01-28 11:17:07

Added by: AMIR TANWAR



Point: as we see that f.d.i has many positive effect and only a few negative point so we can neglect the negative point and make india economically and technologically developed......



Date: 2014-01-27 23:59:35

Added by: Jitendra



Point: the main thing is the economic rate interest difference. foreign organized players sucks max profit from any economy anf also hampers the indegenious industries.



Date: 2013-12-15 05:22:04

Added by: vasudhar



Point: In a broad sense FDI is very much beneficial to Indian economy especially at the times of this financial vulnerability.But in my point of view FDI should only me encouraged in the areas where Indian players were not gaining enough importance in terms of both technological advancements and customer satisfaction like airlines and manufacturing of electronic gadgets so that our imports fromChina and Japan can be drastically reduced.



Date: 2013-11-18 00:23:45

Added by: kanchan gupta



Point: I support fdi but this will indirectly had over the key of indian economy to foreigners coz initially they may attract us( low price ,employment opp.) but sooner monopoly can be eshtablish market may be capture by them



Date: 2013-10-16 04:23:56

Added by: mukesh racha.



Point: point:acc to my view fdi is benificial to india,for everything there are advantages and disadvantages,govt should work more efficiently towards disadvantages and should take a optimum measures for converting it into merit.



Date: 2013-10-05 05:18:39

Added by: Divya Gupta



Point: If Govt will allow entry of FDI in the retail sector, it would be beneficial for the customers as they get the high quality product and also get it at cheap prices, but we need to keep in mind that because of entrance of Fdi our small businesses will not grow. Ofcourse our economy will grow, Govt get the taxes as unorganized sector becomes the organised sector, But we should remember what are our plans of making our nation as SOCIALIST....................



Date: 2013-09-17 14:20:47

Added by: apoorva nigam



Point: in my opinion fdi should not come in small retai sectors.. Since we know india is laking behind in manufacturing. So if fdi is comming in india then why in retailor sector it should come in manufacturing field... Foreing exchang come india bt whn they backtrack it will not effect indian economy..



Date: 2013-08-31 07:36:59

Added by: som



Point: allowing fdi in retail sector in india its cociquences is that it will enhance technical work process of farmer leads to high output....govt hav adequate information abt farmers ....



Date: 2013-08-30 13:53:54

Added by: Irshad Nashir Sayyad



Point: I think FDI is beneficial of Indian Economy as well as devlopment of country. Because India is Developing Country.But drawback of FDI is if the Foreign Country enter in the Indian Market then they start to capture the Domestic Companies



Date: 2013-08-30 03:15:14

Added by: rohitbaba



Point: goverment chutiya hai it will affect the small businessman ,the cottage industry and house hold indusrty ......This will also increase the unemployment as reduced chain and self services stores.We ll again become dependent on outsourcing



Date: 2013-08-29 02:01:09

Added by: senmathi



Point: my point view, i will support fdi becoz we get foreign exposure, it mre benifts farmers, and ecomcic will higher.



Date: 2013-08-18 00:17:15

Added by: BICHU KURIAN THOMAS



Point: in retail fdi i think it is very useful to farmers and it will help to applay modern technolagy to our farm land



Date: 2013-08-12 23:36:33

Added by: RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA



Point: According to my point of view FDI is like a tonic for our economy growth so definatly it should be implimated in INDIA.



Date: 2013-08-07 07:40:40

Added by: Putta Nareah Racharla boppapur.



Point: i think that the fdi may have some advances and disadvances so we must conculeded that our indian samall retailer may not be saffer to have some policys on this issus the governament may take more conclusion on the making of this policys.



Date: 2013-08-04 12:03:38

Added by: vipul gupta



Point: Point:- I think fdi in various sector will boost indian economy because1. It increase infrastructure as well employment.2.It helps in transfer of technology of other countries.3.Fresh investment come in india that will boost indian economy.4.Middleman will eliminated so farmers can sell their product directly in market.5.Some areas like defence, IT, in which india require good technology will push by FDI



Date: 2013-08-03 20:46:11

Added by: INDIAN



Point: I dont think FDI should be implement in india, India is a country where u can get corruption in every department,every place in one word everywhere. suppose if u have government work then u cant do that without giving bribe(GHUS). and if u belong to rich family or some reputed family then u may do that work in very less time and without giving any bribe. so after FDI it will happen more and only those people get benefit and there will be a educated DALAL between farmer and multibrand company,



Date: 2013-07-23 08:52:10

Added by: naresh reddy



Point: there should be a greater involvement by the governament bcz local business traders wind up then there may be a chance of hikes commadities ..that point of time govt.should control such type of situations.



Date: 2013-07-04 23:05:38

Added by: Prashant Motiramani



Point: FDI is too good for India but upto some extent so that it does not affect small scale industries or capture the whole market of India which will adversely affect the Indian economy.



Date: 2013-06-25 10:04:53

Added by: Ashish sharma



Point: according to me FDI in retail sector is not beneficial for India because from retail sector approx. 4 million peoples are employed, if FDI is in retail sector it would unemployed all those who get benefit from retail sector.



Date: 2013-06-24 14:29:40

Added by: ashpreet kaur



Point: 'history repeats itself' if this is the policy behind, then we should immediately terminate all the business taking place across the borders, moreover no point raising the issue of getting slaved by foreign dictators because we already sheltering autocrat ism here, here the talks happen but unfortunately no action. And if the intermediaries i.e. uneducated slash semi educated jobs are to be sacked then RTE probably could get a meaningful face and equality in wage system could be established in India too.



Date: 2013-06-01 09:51:50

Added by: EDAKULAPALLY TEJASWINI



Point: I Think that brining of fdi is good.But it should be useful to all the sectors like, small industries, farmers etc.we should give direct deal with producer to fdi. then our country will be maintain good relation with foerign investments. then it will help to became our country developed.



Date: 2013-05-07 00:19:22

Added by: ARUN CHAUDHARI



Point: Hi friend,I don't think FDI is a better option for india , and modern technology if gov invest more in R



Date: 2013-05-03 18:13:19

Added by: sandeep malik



Point: Its a human nature..we seems to be hesitant in adopting new technologies, idea and policies without considering its possible outcome same goes with FDI ..i believe it here to stay in the long Run coz its potential benefits like creating mass employment , bringing new products , goods and services @ EDLP.



Date: 2013-04-30 02:37:29

Added by: shivam goyal



Point: I think fdi will be good for india.this will bring modern technology in india and it would help build the competitive market. I thing govetnment of india would get 25-30 billion by this way. fdi will bring many jobs for employee. by this way our infrastructure will be increse. and aur country will become a doveloped country



Date: 2013-03-22 11:54:50

Added by: mahima



Point: me too agree history repeats itself .....jin ke haathon se apni aazadi cheeni unhi ke hathon gulaam hote ja rahe hain.....



Date: 2013-03-15 06:22:22

Added by: skundu



Point: "history repeats itself" if FDI is encouraged in our country our condition will soon be like we were 65 years ago.so there is no room for any mistake this time.



Date: 2013-03-09 00:08:29

Added by: dhruvika



Point: fdi will only take india to nothing except the delibrations amongst the political parties who will fight over their own issues and own selfish causes.whatever except some few issues done in india has only been useful to the bureaucratics.....its mere long talks



Date: 2013-03-07 06:52:02

Added by: Nagabhushana reddy.N



Point: Allowing FDI s is good for india.competition is more,then best quality of product reach to.the customer.But the thing is foriegners may leads the indian market ,control the market in their hands.used technology in business.said aboue indian retailers are uneducteds more percentge.



Date: 2013-03-06 12:40:04

Added by: omi



Point: i dont think much -ve impact of allowing fdi retail in India..as its is allowed only in 51 cities.although our government don not have sufficient shelter to protect the amassed food.so its better to sell them to those company n its not like that only uneducated n downtrodden people are getting job in grocery..there are so many other shops where they can work.or they could trainded to work in these companies.



Date: 2013-02-28 07:48:43

Added by: DHEERAJ PANDEY



Point: villagers only know how to produce things.we have to tell them how to market their produce, how to do value addition.give them a strong idea of co-operative farming.In India,farmers have small small holding but if they form a co-operative,it becomes a large holding



Date: 2013-02-28 00:10:21

Added by: little



Point: FDI creates job opportunities that is good . but the products available there should be of our country



Date: 2013-02-22 08:23:21

Added by: sudha reddy



Point: hi friends in my perception coin has both sides like that every aspect has both pros and cons. advantages are 1) prices of consumable products decreases 2) quality of product will be increased 3)it eliminates the middleman's 4)consumer have many choices to buy the product 5) lot of employment opportunities in coming years 6) technological development 7)minimize the wastage some of the disadvantages are 1) It dominate the domestic companies market. 2) it eliminate the small scale business units



Date: 2013-02-22 00:47:44

Added by: amlan



Point: it is really acceptable bcoz it will develope the rural infrastructure and it will bring a compitative market which results consumer will get a better price and mostly our country will be develope.



Date: 2013-02-22 00:38:33

Added by: sandeep verma



Point: indian goverment should allows the f d I in such a conditions that it provides only technologies not products.



Date: 2013-02-21 10:41:32

Added by: Amit Jain



Point: In around 90's when computer's were introduced than even a huge protest was done , but today we all know, how important role they play in our daily life. We need organised retail which will ultimately boost up our economy. Reforms should be taken positively.



Date: 2013-02-18 21:28:31

Added by: Bharat Tandon



Point: why our country always need a foreign hand to solved the which have occured within our domestic boundries



Date: 2013-02-15 22:24:08

Added by: Himali



Point: guys according to me of course FDI should be brought in India........and for those people who are against of it should understand that if in retail sector FDI will be brought by Govt then the benefit will be of consumers only......so that they will not be cheated by every retailors which they are doing nowwwwww........



Date: 2013-02-09 22:56:44

Added by: AKASH TIWARI



Point: ya well it will help in employment generation for we yuth and a golden oppportunity of freedom and time saving in our modern era



Date: 2013-02-09 19:18:51

Added by: Dr V Basil Hans



Point: Very educative, Commerce teachers and students must see....



Date: 2013-02-08 02:41:12

Added by: ROSHIN VARGHESE



Point: hi........when we adopt a particular thing......definitely it have pros and cons........so my opinion is that FDI is good in the sense it benifit the poor farmers.......and improve GDP...but govt must ensure that india should be safe in our own hands......dont let the ways to exploit our people and resources.......



Date: 2013-02-06 09:28:38

Added by: sujata



Point: Friends FDI could bring competition in market, even the use of advance technologies which is necessary to bring nation up, if we have strong giant opponent in market then only we can think something new like adoption of technologies or ideas. otherwise we would be gloomy to changes happening in world.



Date: 2013-02-02 02:58:47

Added by: Shadab Wali



Point: I think Fdi is acceptable on strict conditions like they have to take 60% crops from the Indian Formers and have to give 100% employment to Indian youth.



Date: 2013-01-30 01:39:14

Added by: yogendra patel



Point: if the FDI will come into the India then brain drain problem can be overcome.



Date: 2013-01-28 11:35:58

Added by: komal agarwal



Point: i think FDI should be allowed as it creates job and it will help in optimum utilization of resources but before allowing government should make proper rules and regulations so that it want be a problem for India in future..



Date: 2013-01-27 10:29:37

Added by: Ranju Pradhan



Point: Today we find d fiscal defict in our country N forgn currency helps in some extent in solvng dis problm so India is in need of foregn currency plus FDI facilitates many thing lik emplymnt,dev of economy n many others BUT yes, it's true dat Small businesses will b affected becz dey may nt b able 2 offer d price which d forgn co. Offers usng their modern tech...but if we see it positively,slowly and graduly small firm will learn n use such type of tech and FINALLY improves our economy.:)



Date: 2013-01-26 10:52:20

Added by: avanthika vasu



Point: it is good because farmers and consumers will get benefit.



Date: 2013-01-23 06:35:50

Added by: Anushka



Point: I think FDI should be allowed because of the above mentioned reasons.Also, it won't have an impact on small stores as we can see big bazar, etc came but these shops have still survived.



Date: 2013-01-20 13:38:30

Added by: SAYYED ATEEQUE ZAHEERODDIN



Point: It is a really very good decision by the gov because FDI in retail sector make our economy powerful and it may be helpful to grow our GDP and also it will reduce a inflationary gap in our economy.



Date: 2013-01-15 23:52:21

Added by: Ashish Mehra



Point: FDI is good in India because competition will be high so buyers will gain lot of profit with cheaper rates.and reduces monopoly in the market so its beneficial for buyers and give lots of jobs.so its good step taken by government.



Date: 2013-01-15 09:49:08

Added by: vijay



Point: FDI can be allowed in our country "But products available in these malls should belong to only our country "



Date: 2013-01-12 12:01:21

Added by: vishal jadiya



Point: point: hi friends many of u rightly said that FDI will bring new technology in india and give many jobs in india......BUTTTTTTT gusy if fdi is allowed than all the money which WALLMART or any other foreign compony will earn go directly to their nation and not india...and it will provide jobsof only salesman or sales girl...u want that the youth of india do such jobs...



Date: 2013-01-12 10:06:13

Added by: Kirti Singh 716



Point: the middle class people those who are having shops, there shops could be go in loss.



Date: 2013-01-10 07:48:17

Added by: Rohit Pandarkar



Point: Point: i m against fdi bcoz it will largly affect the small firms in india and alsoon domestic products.it can create unemployement.



Date: 2013-01-06 01:31:54

Added by: PANKAJ MAKVANA



Point: government should allow FDI to INDIA but on certain conditions like...1) 50% products should be from indian companies.2)employement for INDIANs in their malls3)limited years of bonds should be sign4)except INDIA no other country or organisations can take any kind of decisions regarding these malls.



Date: 2013-01-01 12:23:13

Added by: Sunil Krrish 009



Point: Entering FDI in our country, it consists of both Pros and cons, as what below researchers said, finally what I say is it good because it enhances competitive spirit and it helps for unemployment and also it increases the GDP.



Date: 2012-12-31 05:53:07

Added by: Rahul kumar singh



Point: the govt. should allow FDI in indian markets with some strong terms and conditions....



Date: 2012-12-28 15:19:57

Added by: GAURAV SHARMA



Point: fdi is good fr ind bcz it ll bring many modern technology ,



Date: 2012-12-25 21:21:59

Added by: vishnu



Point: No FDI, should not be introduced, though initially they start the mkt with low price after few yrs, they eventually rate their prices .... and also as per statistics where ever FDI was introduced it showed majority of FAILURE ... our politicain r wanting for money n tats the reason , they r dying hard



Date: 2012-12-24 11:35:44

Added by: Guru Prasad



Point: Allowing FDI has pros and cons.coming to pros,many unemployed will be employed.Farmers get fair prices for their goods.Wastage of agricultural product will be less and can be used efficiently.Government gets billions of USD in d form of taxes.coming to cons,many middlemen who are dependent on retail businesses will face many problems.



Date: 2012-12-18 07:11:31

Added by: Lt. harish kumar



Point: i dnt think fdi is going to b a sucess cos as per the census 67% of the kirana shops were closed whn fdi stepped in thailand,instead of gtng ppl jobs it snatchd whatsoevr they hd....and as they said ki farmers vl b the biggest beneficiaries i must tell u ki they(foreign retailers) vl b hvng 70% of the requisite stuff from international cheap sources that they hv 30% from our domestic sources only if they find our stuff adequate enuf 2 b bought......



Date: 2012-12-17 04:25:56

Added by: hemant kumar



Point: i think fdi is useful in india because it create an satisfy world in this time fdi born many good ideas in business world and it is purely change our economy if it is run in positive way



Date: 2012-12-16 09:03:09

Added by: Preeti Aggarwal



Point: though it is considered that FDI is good for India, which might be true as it will provide employment to so many degree holders and will enhance demand of more skilled people, but what about the small shopkeepers having shops in local areas, what about the people living in backward areas and have small income. Will they be able to afford the prices offered by these retail sectors.



Date: 2012-12-16 06:40:48

Added by: sonali patil



Point: Government is thinking that FDI will boost our economy but this concept is good for short term. For long term it will be like monopoly, so if FDI come in India for long term then Govt. should take precautionary majors.



Date: 2012-12-14 11:35:34

Added by: chandu naidu



Point: yes friends , farmers get more benifits through FDIs by direct trade business without supply chain managment.farmers are the back bone of our country, if they are very well then country like india will definetly add into the list of developing countries.surly it happens



Date: 2012-12-14 09:13:42

Added by: PREETY KUMARI SONI



Point: having seen the issue raised on FDI,i think the indian government is not considering on future results of allowing FDI in reatail market...because if we see 60 or 70 years back then we find the foreigners came in india through indusrialization and slowly they captured the whole India and made Indian slave...so allowing FDI is intviting again to capture INDIAN market and economy and then whole INDIA.....so, I am not in favour of FDI seeing the future of INDIA..



Date: 2012-12-13 00:06:57

Added by: Syed Asif Mehdi



Point: I think through FDI we can solve the problem of unemployment in India and beside this it would help in making revenue for the country and by this revenue we could solve the problem of poverty.



Date: 2012-12-10 07:07:27

Added by: Vijay raje(sps) baori jodhpur



Point: I'm not in favour of FDI bt also not against.....bcoz.......its partialy good bt also bad for poor farmers



Date: 2012-12-09 07:06:20

Added by: Neha



Point: I oppose FDI. under my opinion FDI may be beneficial on short term but never for long term..i dont understand y india cannot do on its own..y do we need Foreign investors..n we should ask to r self that wether really FDI is worth.?



Date: 2012-12-07 08:24:54

Added by: Abhijeet



Point: I don't think that this is the right time for FDI in india. we still need to improve our manufacturing sector. else FDI will be like SHOPS OF AMERICA GODDS OF CHINA AND BUYERS OF INDIA... LOSERS INDIANS.



Date: 2012-12-06 09:01:30

Added by: yash madhurendra



Point: FDI will bea benefit in long term and as a major problem of 21st century is of price hike so it will also solve that problem.



Date: 2012-12-05 22:48:37

Added by: abhishek



Point: this is not good for india, polticians are going to selling our india to foreigner. in last 200 years the foreigner were come in india as the traditional company and after that they take interest in indian poltic, and now that is also going on like that



Date: 2012-12-05 20:19:57

Added by: 94590-61368



Point: this is not good for india, polticians are going to selling our india to foreigner. in last 200 years the foreigner were come in india as the traditional company and after that they take interest in indian poltic, and now that is also going on like that



Date: 2012-12-05 20:19:45

Added by: Prashant Kaushik



Point: no it is not good because the FDI is come India the small business are closed



Date: 2012-12-05 00:35:18

Added by: JOEL D'CRUZE



Point: my point of view FDI will affect 50 million merchant in India. This can create unemployment,an economically backward class person suffers from price rise,workers safety and policies are not mentioned clearly.Again India became slaves because of FDI in retail sector.......



Date: 2012-12-04 23:16:42

Added by: MD RAHMAT KARIM



Point: yes it is very necessary to allow FDI in retail sector as it will increase the level of competency and no doubt it will boost up the speed of productivity of domestic companies.



Date: 2012-11-30 10:19:30

Added by: samarth agrawal



Point: fdi is good for short run plan but will be harmful for long run as foreign investers through their monopoly power try to compress the economy. hence proper check should be made on it.



Date: 2012-11-30 04:14:45

Added by: palak mukherjee



Point: i belive in indian talent i.e our skill of productivity n business...we already tought a lesson n it'll nt reapet this tym...this tym we attack in a more stronger way....fdi'll lead our indian companies more qualitative and world class so welcome fdi



Date: 2012-11-29 09:04:53

Added by: Madhulika Shandilya



Point: With the centre giving its nod on FDI in the multibrand retail sector, the debate on its pros and cons have started like a wildfire. while farmers and consumers in the state welcomed it, some sectioned have viewed their apprehensions on the intention of foreign players. A middlemen earning a fortune from his produce but his condition remained oreover the same. but i think it will help us in fetching more prices for our products, so i am all ok with it.



Date: 2012-11-29 08:36:09

Added by: himanshu soni



Point: farmers will be benefited once..bt later on fdi will occupy thier land or farmers will sell their land to gain profit nd fdi will grow their own products,then retailers will have to beg to the fdi for their products nd fdi wil definately hike the price and earn profit,,,as their is not other options left for the retailers except to buy from fdi at high pricesultimately indian bussiness will BE effected badlyIS FDI WILL COME IN INDIA..THEN ONE DAY WILL COME WHEN FDI WILL RULE WHOLE INDIA...



Date: 2012-11-23 22:37:39

Added by: Shivmangal Choudhary (student of TJC)



Point: Acc 2 me if FDI will welcome in our country then it will standarised our living and it is good for us.



Date: 2012-11-22 04:42:39

Added by: Musaddique



Point: FDI should welcome. because it will increase competition for indian companies those are slow and also it is beneficial for customers that they can get products will lowest price. also it will solve the problem of unemployment in india. many of people will get jobs. according to these i think that FDI should be welcome an it will become good for india to develop.



Date: 2012-11-21 12:42:49

Added by: malar pink rose



Point: i am always against the fdi because it cause the india economically backward



Date: 2012-11-21 08:09:25

Added by: Md Emaduddin vil po -bara dist-gaya



Point: yes it is very very good for our country thanxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxMd Emad add ansar mohalla, nirsa,, dhanbad



Date: 2012-11-21 05:52:26

Added by: Kavana



Point: The question raised by Mr. Ankur Yadav is worth to be considered. Moreover, FDI in retail sector will put the middlemen and their dependents life into trouble.



Date: 2012-11-19 03:19:16

Added by: Rameez



Point: Wether forign direct investment is neccessary in retailed trade sector in india



Date: 2012-11-11 20:24:30

Added by: umer awwab



Point: according to me if farmer exactly no what is fdi than they wil definetly favoure on the goverment .and also fdi wil nt cut the job they need many employes and creat more job in the country wit this we can solve the issues of employment...



Date: 2012-11-11 04:54:08

Added by: saggu



Point: according to me FDI good for india bacause now a days in india all things which we purchase to the shopkeprs include all the taxes and one more thng is include in it ..such as the small scale company gived the money to the poltics for extra things thn company increase the price of the things..so all money pay by customor if fdi comes in india thn all this thngs are abrogate



Date: 2012-11-10 01:22:06

Added by: Ankur yadav



Point: Its true that initially the farmers are going to make good business.but will the same condition sustain 10 years down the line???



Date: 2012-11-08 20:12:21

Added by: Anuj kumar (Patna)



Point: No I am not favor of FDI. Becoz I naver want to give our freedom in foreigners hand.....



Date: 2012-11-08 10:45:30

Added by: pankaj andani



Point: what i think is...our country is not going anywhere right now....there are lots of ministers greedy for money....the money gov. announes for farmers...dey never got them.....so at least this FDI thing will be transparent... nd dis 1 million criteria is also good....SO WE CAN GIVE IT A TRY FOR 3-4 YEARS IN METRO CITIES ND DEN CAN DECIDE FURTHER .



Date: 2012-11-06 08:10:46

Added by: abhishek



Point: what about the predatory pricing these gaints will adopt.



Date: 2012-11-05 08:05:31

Added by: shailesh negi



Point: FDI MUST BE IMPOSE IN RETAIL REGARDING THERE MUST BE CERTAIN LIMITS FOR THAT.........



Date: 2012-11-03 22:15:48

Added by: ANAND SHANKAR



Point: FDI in the retail sector is the right decision in the favour of indian interest but we should secure our farmers and unorganised traders interest . Our policy should be general people welfare centric.....



Date: 2012-10-28 03:18:03

Added by: Rajan kr Tiwari



Point: Acc to me india allows FDI but in one condition if FDI will not correctly then it should be withdraw otherwise it will be bad 4 our country..



Date: 2012-10-20 23:06:28

Added by: richa



Point: Point:Fdi is not gud for our country .Many of peoples become unemployed bez due to fdi foreign product demands wil be increased no one use the indian product .



Date: 2012-10-17 12:17:00

Added by: Ved Joshi



Point: How can our nation develop on borrowed money.? We need to help our own entrepreneur to develop by trusting them and showing faith on their brands. We should not avoid local brands.Ved



Date: 2012-10-17 10:00:39

Added by: niraj kumar



Point: it will increase competition in all sector,poor will face problem.it should come in medical sector so that medicine can be bought cheaper,



Date: 2012-10-16 22:55:28

Added by: GURPREET



Point: FDI is okay taht will lead to decline in poverty only if the manufacturing starts in india. I am masters and want to do something for my community.like i want to go for manufacturing of sanitary napkins for rural female, but there is no answer from any site.what will fdi do?



Date: 2012-10-14 07:11:50

Added by: nikita



Point: according to me fdi must be allowed in India. for the great future



Date: 2012-10-12 22:02:41

Added by: jitendra patel



Point: it can be dominated in our country so dont allow FDI because if will be dominate in our then FDI may be monopoly so it is very difficult situation for our country



Date: 2012-10-12 09:26:01

Added by: jitendra patel



Point: point: FDI will help in our country because we adopt new technology and we improve our productivity through support FDI retaining because small farmer have no enough money they will adopt new technology so FDI will help difinate



Date: 2012-10-12 09:18:15

Added by: snehal



Point: i am completely in favour of FDI as..today fdi isnt implemented and we know in what state india is.. instead give FDI a try..a change is always beneficial.. and if it doesnt work it could be withdrawn..



Date: 2012-10-11 09:24:10

Added by: Jujbir singh



Point: Acc to my views fdi is nt good for our country. The shopkeepers become unemployd nd the many of persns become unemployd. Due to fdi foreign product demands should increase nd no one should use indian product people were found nd craze of foreign product nd they forget their culture also.. So fdi should nt be a part of our country



Date: 2012-10-11 02:18:33

Added by: Apoorva Arora



Point: Instead of bringing fdi we should promote our small businessman to start high technology based business. Buy technology from them, why give them a chance to earn from us like we did once during 18th century giving chance to east India company.Also USA doesn't want Indians to work in US and we want to give business to them who doesn't want to give us work.



Date: 2012-10-10 22:23:24

Added by: ankitbharne



Point: fdi come in india because they are a very big supplier of commodities and other think and emprove of transport system of india and improve of management



Date: 2012-10-10 11:02:31

Added by: sonika Singhal



Point: As per my concern , FDI should not allow in India as soon it become the leader and then the condition would be worst than bad , as we are not in a position to allow FDI because currently we do have a high degree of people who are not able to fed them and again the question would take place on their survival. So , FDI shouldn't allowed as people are more important as compared to INFRASTRUCTURE , Advance Technology etc.



Date: 2012-10-10 01:50:41

Added by: RAMASHISH VERMA , MNNIT ALLAHABAD



Point: According to my view FDI in multibrand retail should allowed in india , because when foreign compnies will set up their business in india ,it will be a chance of employement , compettion in the market and it directly will give advantages to the common man and government can get taxes to that companies. We would be also aware to new technology .



Date: 2012-10-08 09:55:41

Added by: sneha saraf



Point: FDI in retail should be welcomed in India because the brands we dream of and has to be imported can easily,widely,and at comparitively cheap be available.



Date: 2012-10-06 06:25:49

Added by: liznan



Point: Why traffic rules are not followed as per foreign countries? Why traffic is detained for Ministers' vehicles to go ahead and not for Ambulance or Fire Brigade vehicles?



Date: 2012-10-06 04:14:04

Added by: liznan



Point: If the technology is executed at Govt. level and rules



Date: 2012-10-06 04:11:04

Added by: liznan



Point: If the technology is executed at Govt. level and rules



Date: 2012-10-06 04:10:56

Added by: liznan



Point: What benefit poor farmers had when Sharad Pawar visited Israel for improved agriculture prodcts and technology? Why are farmers' cases of suicide increasing? When any Minister visits foreign country for its technology, why still in India Solar Energy Products are not made compulsory for every home or building as in Foreign countries like Israel?



Date: 2012-10-06 04:09:52

Added by: liznan



Point: When Indian Products are banned in Foreign Countries for various reasons, why should Foreign Products and Investors allowed in India?



Date: 2012-10-06 04:08:55

Added by: Rajesh Mhade.



Point: i think FDI is new think for develop our country. it should good for farmers.The gov. of india sould take positive dicision about FDI. The dicision will help farmers profitable and removing the middlemen from the supply chain. And generate the new jobs.



Date: 2012-10-05 23:39:10

Added by: RAM MOHAN SINHA(SIETM,UNNAO)



Point: it is correct and should be implemented in india as soon as possible so that our economy can also withstand in the queue of developing.



Date: 2012-10-05 13:16:46

Added by: Tushar



Point: hii guys i think that rupees will even go down that is 1 dollar will become 60 to 70 rupess and will face a gr8 difficulty in international market or the people planning to go to foreign countries as they have to save 60 to 70 rupees to make 1 dollar instead of 50 rupess is it true guys?as per my guessing it is true



Date: 2012-10-05 02:25:12

Added by: ram krashna sharma



Point: here we can also add that FDI will bring the employment in India it will increase more jobs which is very much impotent its means that FDI has potential to creation jobs and employment. It will also help full to growing our economy.Additionally for investors, FDI provides the benefits of reduced cost through the realization of scale economies, and coordination advantages, especially for integrated supply chains.



Date: 2012-10-04 13:00:18

Added by: ashish chaurasiya allahabad



Point: If fdi come in india this is not beneficial, for us bcz as you no vary well they seen the our economy and system they do not want india become a develop country.india should want make this type system then more benifet for all.



Date: 2012-10-04 12:18:22

Added by: kalpesh gujrathi



Point: i m also i favor bcoz it's provid one kind of support to those people who wants to do something in life but they are not able to do only bcoz of the financial support and the FDI are halping to such people..



Date: 2012-10-04 11:30:42

Added by: Puja F.



Point: I think India should not allow FDI.. It will be like we are giving our freedom in foreigners hand again... we cant earn the profit from FDI but it will be loss of the middle class families in future..



Date: 2012-10-04 05:54:43

Added by: devendra kumar ojha mca



Point: BY The fdi we will definataly decrease the economy of india ..because indian ruppe pass out from india and this is not good for us..so fdi must not establish in india.



Date: 2012-10-02 08:20:40

Added by: mukesh mali



Point: In my opinion india should allow to foregion company because of that if they work in india its good for india we will get new thoughts and new idea's and technology.Formr can get good income for their goods and it will decrease our unemployment also..



Date: 2012-10-02 02:43:55

Added by: santosh kumar



Point: as per my think fdi should not be welcomed in reail market in india because noone wants to do any thing until who is not being benifited benifit will go in term of money another country and what about they people they are doing small kind of business in our country they will suffer what they will do after welcoming of fdi in india



Date: 2012-09-27 22:52:02

Added by: Dr.ADUSUMALLI VENKATESWARA RAO



Point: Government policy on FDI definitely benefits a lot to our economy in the long run so as we must invite that without any hesitation because this policy has 70 per centage of benefits/merits



Date: 2012-09-26 01:41:01

Added by: akanksha kumari



Point: according to shop and establishment act state government has right to permit the multi retailers in their state. so it is very good option for a state



Date: 2012-09-25 21:45:07

Added by: NABEEL.N



Point: In the present context there is no need for multi-brand retail because, in India nw there is single brand retail system. if we allowing the fdi it will affect our country adversly, we have the experience that east india company,.. the history will repeat if we allow fdi........ thnx



Date: 2012-09-25 10:52:57

Added by: Sanjiv Kumar Yadav



Point: it may be help in sale of Indian Product and increase of Indian employment so that is beneficial for India.....



Date: 2012-09-25 06:49:49

Added by: mohit kant gupta



Point: I think fdi in india is present time need but govt. Take this decision under pressure...and hastlyi think govt. Should take time n frame some policies to control multi brand retail stores in india...and restrict them from merger or... eqasition



Date: 2012-09-25 05:45:11

Added by: Pushpendra Hazari



Point: I think there are many vantages of FDI,but it should up to some extent governed by the government i.e.there should be the control over it because if foreign investors reduces the prices to a great extent then in the later stages almost max. kirana shops are closed and ultimately after some years there will be the monopoly of the foreign investors.



Date: 2012-09-25 02:33:54

Added by: anna



Point: according to me,india should allow FDI but to small extend.likewise-in 1997 up to 2010 india allow FDI in cash and carry wholesale.ANOTHER POINT I WANT TO SHARE WITH YOU- it should be mandatory to sale 30-40%of the indian products.if indian government take such steps then i think FDI in india cause benifits.



Date: 2012-09-23 18:13:19

Added by: Rekha Acchelal Sonkhar



Point: Foreign direct investment means increasing employment and economic growth.Co-ordination between small retailer and foreign retailer.small retailer can be selling product higher rate and wont foreign goods.



Date: 2012-09-23 03:24:55

Added by: devesh



Point: Seeing the present scenario of country it is high time to bring about the change by allowing FDI india more inclined towards future will have a positive effect of increasing FDI rates.moreover this will bring a rise in country economy, help farmer to sell there product at higher rate and for me welcome FDI and walmart



Date: 2012-09-22 23:44:24

Added by: PRASHANT KUMAR GOSWAMI



Point: If we think in mind with the socialist approach,FDI in India will creat serious anomalies in supply chail maqnagement due to bad management environment.



Date: 2012-09-22 04:30:06

Added by: shubhada



Point: competition = lowcost = efficiency = consumer welfare . Its HIGH time for india to come out of its old ghold socialistic pattern economy. we must start taking challenges othrwise ecomy will rust into stagnation circle , subsidies irrational political support to local businessmen = curruption = inflation = no growth n no reforms .



Date: 2012-09-20 12:48:25

Added by: sathya(executive company secretary)



Point: every coin has two sides In the same way fdi in retail sector has more pros and cons even though it benefits in many ways such as economic progression, inflation slow down, employment opportunities but affecting retailers and middlemen is unavoidalble, they will suffer a lot.. for ex: soft drinks with the evasion of coke and pepsi local barads like kalimark, mappilai vinayagar lose their market, but thinking about the country as a whole we need it for survival



Date: 2012-09-20 11:22:22

Added by: Ishan Gupta



Point: Point: I think the implementation of FDI in retail sector will allow a much needed inflow of foreign exchange into our reserves which will help the ailing value of rupee against dollar and also aid our retarding economic growth.



Date: 2012-09-20 09:17:36

Added by: Ganesh Devre



Point: Hi there,Article is presented well, no doubt, with points which are likely to be seen by maximum viewers in favor of accepting FDI In India.BUT "A Big BUT"That FDI is seen by two ways:1) A big opportunity for getting best prices on products/articles.2) As debth threat to all the Kirana Shops, Retailers, Traders



Date: 2012-09-20 07:14:05

Added by: Suhaib Haseeb Ahmad



Point: As I think government of India should pass FDI. It is because neither ministry of finance nor any other ministry nor general public get any harm by FDI. And we live in the era of 21st century. No one can make any one slave. Because India is also a specific member of IMF. And a general member of W.T.O. So people has to understand that there will nothing go wrong after passing it. As there are 100 countries invested In FDI.



Date: 2012-09-20 04:14:20

Added by: Nivetha



Point: If small retailers and other sellers have good quality means then y they are to be afraid of fdi. If they sell the commodities at a fair price and do atleast some justice to smaller farmers they wont go to foreign items.



Date: 2012-09-18 09:38:34

Added by: Ajay shanker pandey



Point: There z pros and cons but if we see present time then we will find unemployement is so hight and we know india is agricultural countsy and it wil5 be bbenificial for india.



Date: 2012-09-17 09:12:28

Added by: Aravind.S



Point: In foreign direct investment in India means, our economic growth will increases and also employment.The major disadvantage of this,all the necessary decisions can taken only foreign countries because (51% of share).



Date: 2012-09-17 06:39:52

Added by: siddharth



Point: there r pros and cons attached to everything but looking at d broader aspect FDI should be allowed in india bcoz in d past also there were people who hv opposed rajiv gandhi's decision of bringing IT revolution in our country and its d IT sector which provides d largest employment in india, so y not fdi in retail ..... i strong ly support gov's decision .



Date: 2012-09-16 01:41:17

Added by: sunil kumar



Point: at presently it is badly needed to improve our economic growth which has been stalled and as a result our rating has gone down. It is step in right direction but is taken very late it should have been done much earlier. political perties will se their own gains and agendas but CII



Date: 2012-09-15 14:23:40

Added by: Amrrita ganguly



Point: FDI in retail sector will ensure financially strong business houses to enter into the retail market.apparently it sounds and felt healthy for social economical growth because it will be argued and a fact also that it will generate employment.



Date: 2012-09-15 13:48:12

Added by: Aditi



Point: I am against the fdi bill.since it will lead to unemployment..and we will again get dependent on foreign companies and it will reduce the income of small retailers. Nobody will go to small retaile's shop in front of wall mart......



Date: 2012-09-15 13:45:28

Added by: vaibhav bhardwajucr



Point: frnds:-P we all want to progress but we cant risk our own existence fr the sole reasn so called "development".Every one knows indian market will nt be able to compete fdi henceford will lose our existence in future.And in future if we want onlyto be toys in others hands then only this decision is right.



Date: 2012-09-15 11:21:39

Added by: Jaywant Pandhare



Point: Why Indian market need foreign money when we have ample investors in our own country. Allowing FDI will only bring us foreign currencies, but people who say farmers will get more value for their product is not realistic fact because there is no clear assurance declared or given as such. If we talk about job opportunities that is the concern about Indian government who has to take decisions to motivate domestic investors and offer them to initiatives.Already there is hyper markets are established in Indian market who does same thing to purchase good from the direct sources and giving benifits to customers. money scamed by the currept politianís should be pulled back and divert into progress plans. India is not poor contry to look at others for the help to grow Indian market, we are the only can improve ourself.Indian government should focus more on exporting Indian product in foreign market instead of import other countries goods in India. Instead of encouraging Politianís with their scams with huge amount, Indian government should have to pull back black money lying in swiss bank. It is always good to encourage our own people to groove up.



Date: 2012-09-12 13:33:27

Added by: Prafulla Hazarika



Point: Must allow FDI..1)It will increase employment.2)We will get daily consuming products in cheap price. 3)New technology will develop.4)Govt will get huge tax.5)Farmers will get fair price for their products.In my view,y sud I care for middle man..they increase the price in their manner and we must know that only 8-10% people are middle man out of total population..and using or allowing of fdi doesnt mean we will be slave again,just think do you feel independent,after independence.No side effects of FDI..



Date: 2012-09-12 03:03:41

Added by: Harpreet Hanjra



Point: HI All ,This is good step to move to progress for India . It should allow FDI retailer to enter in india . It will reduce the cost of products and helps to consumer to sell their goods with better price. I am satisfied with his decision to make the india as developed country . It will remove middle man who take huge advantages with this. It also reduce the corruption in India. RegardsHanjra



Date: 2012-09-10 12:03:53

Added by: Hussain Yakub Momin



Point: can i get all necessary topics related GD regarding current affairs,FDI,



Date: 2012-09-06 12:11:36

Added by: Alok dwivedi



Point: In my view 49% FDI should be allowed because if we provide 51% FDI than the decision making power will be in their hands..so they can do anything they want..but if 49% FDI is allowed then before taking any decision they will have to ask us which is good for us...



Date: 2012-08-28 04:58:07

Added by: Pawan Verma



Point: My opinion is that FDI in retail should be allow in India because its has as lots of benifits for farmers, consumer and its also major role in our National Income. In my concerned every such kind of proposals have prons



Date: 2012-08-25 10:39:32

Added by: Bhujagasayana Nandyala



Point: 1.Very large MNCs reduce purchase prices, renegotiate contracts with farmers or Small / Medium Industrialists to the disadvantage of locals. 2.As MNCs buy / choose 'A' or 'B'grade produce, farmers get very low value for remaining produce.3.Local operators like labour, shop workers, etc., are replaced by efficient machines.



Date: 2012-08-23 07:43:13

Added by: nitin kumar sagar



Point: as mr deepak kumar said that middle men will be removed and farmers will get more revenues then where wud the middle men go and what if the farmers are not able to grow more because of less rain,so fdi shud be denied.



Date: 2012-08-18 11:43:00

Added by: somyajit



Point: fdi should be implemented.from this we can earn the foreign money and it should be help our economic imbalance.



Date: 2012-08-09 12:06:16

Added by: Raju



Point: Yeah , FDI should be implemented. It develops the marketing and good relationship between two countries



Date: 2012-08-04 10:02:12

Added by: shafiq



Point: if fdi pass in india so there may be chance of unemployment it will effect those people who run there bussines in hawker paddler kiranas



Date: 2012-08-02 06:17:56

Added by: Dushyant



Point: Point - 1. How Many of you are worked or working in retail?Point - 2. How many of you belong to a farmer family?All the smart educated persons sitting in their cabin discuss about FDI, retail, Agriculture reform, supply chain, warehousing.



Date: 2012-08-01 05:49:57

Added by: jitendra



Point: aCORDING TO MY POINT OF VIEW FDI WILL SHOULD BE PASS



Date: 2012-07-27 05:13:46

Added by: himanshu



Point: If foreign companies come in India now then what is difference before and after getting freedom Ok We will get dollars but importance of rupee will decreaseNow our money is only in India's hands ,they may want more profit but we can say it our indians people and moneyBlack money key is fdi



Date: 2012-07-04 14:28:41

Added by: himanshu



Point: If foreign companies come in India now then what is difference before and after getting freedom Ok We will get dollars but importance of rupee will decreaseNow our money is only in India's hands ,they may want more profit but we can say it our indians people and moneyBlack money key is fdi



Date: 2012-07-04 14:28:35

Added by: prachi



Point: farmers of India has to face tough competition with high quality agricultural produce,. of course India is the leading producer in agriculture but still the quality is not up to internatinal standards.



Date: 2012-06-21 03:02:00

Added by: NIBATHRA



Point: the scenario reveal that it will take our country back to a dependent on foreign traders



Date: 2012-06-06 10:59:21

Added by: priyal maheshwari



Point: FDI is seriously good for educated ppl bt ths is nt d matter tht it s good only fr them....un-edu. nd semi edu. ppl can also get training and development osn tht they will be trained nd can increase productivity....over all it is good fr our country in incrsng foreign currency....nd wll bring modern techonology.



Date: 2012-05-28 02:15:28

Added by: Devesh Raj



Point: thank you in this Topic Becoz topic is very simple



Date: 2012-05-25 07:31:08

Added by: Atif Khatri



Point: Allowing FDI in retail will spread the business of our country to a great extent but this can turn positive or negative depending upon the conditions........



Date: 2012-05-03 06:20:42

Added by: MehdiSyed



Point: Well, FDI, will bring the employment opportunity and improve the economic condition, and will imrove the PPE.... the bill should be passed..........



Date: 2012-04-26 10:30:21

Added by: Moinuddin



Point: But allowing FDI in India would also lead to a loss of employment for many as a majority of village population earns their living through kirana stores as their only source of living...Plus this may even swoop a large chunk of the profits outside the country



Date: 2012-04-22 03:41:57

Added by: RAJ



Point: its good, short and simple(vital points)........easy to remember..........



Date: 2012-04-19 09:06:00

Added by: Ninad Trivedi



Point: FDI or not is an issue same as a fight between an opportunist and an optimist. FDI would be having long term profits, but assume the scenario when Wal-marts are around you. Would you go to small retailers, even out chains like D-mart, BigB will be in loss. If it is all about agri then you motivate D-mart or BigB to buy directly from farmers.



Date: 2012-04-18 01:41:23

Added by: sethu madhavan



Point: All we know the middle man or the rich people buy mostly the products from retail chain in india, consumer spending per per person/ per family is getting increased compare to the old age because we purchase based on what we gets from a super market and not based on what we require. This may create a culture in the society to buy more without much focus on our pockets using credit cards etc..



Date: 2012-04-15 00:30:12

Added by: POOJA KADAM



Point: GOOD TOPIC,... CAN YOU PLEASE SUGGEST MORE TOPIC...(ENTRANCE) FOR GD PI for MASTERS IN FASHION MANAGEMENT ,NIFT. ITS URGENT



Date: 2012-04-12 02:12:24

Added by: Naushad



Point: FDI will create a lots of competition in the market and because of that goods price will be cheap . FDI will increase the Economic activity so more jobs will be created.and uneducated or semieducated people can be trained to get more productivity



Date: 2012-04-07 10:04:42

Added by: megha



Point: FDI SHOULD NOT BE THERE CZ IT WILL CRUB D EARNING OF SMALL TRADERS N DEALERS



Date: 2012-03-29 11:04:42

Added by: CA. Vedavyas Molleti



Point: India can allow FDI in multi branding retail, but it should monitor the commodity prices closely to control the price inflation to strengthening Indian Economy. And it also put restriction on Foreign Retail Company in importing importing goods and services because it will hit the domestic industries and services.



Date: 2012-03-28 09:52:14

Added by: Ashish raghav



Point: By allowing fdi in retail we can minimize middle persons because we can see that because of them the rates of daily commodities are growing because they bought at 10 and sale that on 20 so we should allow fdi in retail and from fdi we will get approx 20 billion $ in way taxes and from it we can grow jobs to those middle persons



Date: 2012-03-27 06:25:07

Added by: swapnil



Point: The greatest advantage in allowing FDI is tax collection. Today india has a large number of small shops selling commodities. These shopkeepers sell adulterated material and also invade taxes. There is no way to monitor these small shops moreover the labours working at such shops get minimal salary and dont have any future safty for job. Allowing FDI will help oraganize the retail sector and will lead to propperous India..



Date: 2012-03-26 01:04:30

Added by: Ravi



Point: From my concern fdi will allow to india.because more foreigon curreny come to rbi.this is through dollar will be reduce.and all produts rate is down and agri products get more price then revenue rate will high,tax etc.fdi retail should not impact the small retailers.many people get more job oppertunites from fdi for both edu



Date: 2012-03-25 09:05:36

Added by: Ravi



Point: According to in my point of view, fdi in retail sector should allow to india.because it will creating more employement oppertunites for all type of people,and agri produts get more fair price. Govt get more benefit of tax.all sides segment through govt get tax.



Date: 2012-03-24 08:47:54

Added by: pranay



Point: i completely agree that fdi should be let in our country because government has the provision in this policy that that the company must buy at least their 30% of the raw material from the local market. this would definitely fetch the farmer the best price and as it is said that only 53 big cities are there where it will come so i think the local people would get benefited.



Date: 2012-03-23 06:02:58

Added by: RAVI KUMAR TIWARI



Point: point: from my concern, if fdi will investing the money(only) nt the resource like employee in india then there is no problem for indians.



Date: 2012-03-22 09:16:14

Added by: nikhil dhumale



Point: i also think FDI will decrease the cost of various roduct so that it will be benefitial to poor people and also get the jobs to peoples.



Date: 2012-03-21 05:59:15

Added by: nupur soni



Point: it will surely good and beneficial foe indian farmers..... they should have to know about this technology....



Date: 2012-03-21 00:46:12

Added by: Ninad taywade



Point: fdi should be let in, nly if it promises to get the unemployed and uneducated people secure jobs. This wud apply nly for the people who has a small buisness but those people who have a large set up, why wud those people want to work for nybody.



Date: 2012-03-14 23:55:33

Added by: kumar



Point: in my point of view if fdi will come into our country then it will be beneficial for our country in many ways, like our country today facing with some big problems like inflation,corruption etcwhich is seriously eating our country.but there is also a fear in our country people that retail stores will grab the small stores and businesses, for that i think if foreign retail stores ensure that they will provide jobs to uneducated people with educated then these will help them.



Date: 2012-03-09 08:49:29

Added by: vikrant tegta



Point: new technolgy should be introduced to the farmers so that they can get the maximum benefit..n it wil lead to the upliftment of national income as a whole



Date: 2012-03-08 11:28:41

Added by: samip kumar



Point: when we dont have a good storage system,then its better to have a system where companies will bye products directly from farmers.It will help the farmers in a sense that they will get good value for their crops.That will also reduce the amount of middle man factor working in our country.



Date: 2012-02-17 14:22:06

Added by: alok kumar



Point: i can see the scenario is grim,many one taking fdi wil lead the retailing system as a frontier but what abut small retailers those lively hood is dwindling and what about 40% of uneducated and downtrodden?so govt wil introspect and make a advisory body and strict law in retailing if they allow tesco walmart like giant retailing company................



Date: 2012-02-13 11:57:15

Added by: saurabh_NIAM



Point: big retail companies will provide advisory service for the farmers that is the thing which Indian agriculture need.we have latest technology for improving productivity but farmers does not know how to use them.



Date: 2012-01-15 23:50:29

Added by: Sorav Agarwal



Point: Please read this book "Wal-Mart: The Bully of Bentonville: How the High Cost of Everyday Low Prices is Hurting America"



Date: 2011-12-26 12:57:55